Exempt vs Non-Exempt Trust: Canadian Charity Guide
Canadian charities often hold property through various trust arrangements. Understanding whether these trusts are exempt or non-exempt from reporting requirements has become complex.
Recent changes to trust reporting rules under the Income Tax Act have created new obligations for charities. These changes affect how charities manage internal trusts, endowment funds, and donor-advised funds.
Many organizations remain uncertain about which trusts must file T3 returns. Others wonder which trusts can rely on existing exemptions.
The main difference between exempt and non-exempt trusts for Canadian charities is that registered charities structured as trusts do not need to file separate T3 returns. Internal express trusts held by charities may face new reporting requirements depending on specific circumstances and Canada Revenue Agency guidance.
This distinction affects many charitable organizations across Canada. It is especially important for those that manage multiple restricted funds or accept gifts with conditions attached.
The stakes are high for charities that misclassify their trust arrangements. Organizations could face compliance issues, penalties, or administrative burdens if they misunderstand their reporting obligations.
Understanding the technical requirements helps charities maintain their focus on charitable work. It also ensures they meet their legal responsibilities.
Overview of Trusts in Canadian Charities
Trusts are legal arrangements that allow charities to hold and manage property on behalf of beneficiaries. They help registered charities maintain donor-restricted gifts, manage endowment funds, and operate specialized programs.
Definition of Trusts
A trust is a legal relationship where one party holds property for the benefit of another. In registered charities, an express trust creates legally binding obligations through clear terms and conditions.
An express trust requires three certainties: intention to create a trust, subject matter (the property held), and objects (the beneficiaries). The charity acts as trustee when it receives property with enforceable terms and conditions.
Internal trusts form when a registered charity receives a gift with specific restrictions and holds that property as trustee. Bare trusts differ because the trustee only holds legal title and has no active duties beyond transferring property when directed.
Role of Trusts in Charitable Operations
Trusts held by charities help organizations honour donor intentions and maintain legal compliance. When a donor gives money for a specific purpose, the charity must respect those restrictions as a trustee.
Endowment funds often use trust structures to preserve capital and use investment income for charitable activities. Donor-advised funds allow donors to recommend grants while the charity maintains legal control.
A charitable foundation may hold multiple trusts, each serving different programs or donor requirements. These arrangements let organizations segregate funds while maintaining unified governance.
Trustee responsibilities require charities to manage property prudently and use it according to the trust terms.
Types of Trust Structures Used by Charities
Registered charities use several trust configurations. Restricted fund trusts hold donations designated for specific purposes, such as building funds or scholarship programs.
Endowment trusts preserve the original gift amount while making investment returns available for spending. Some endowments require perpetual preservation, while others allow spending after a set period.
Memorial trusts honour individuals or causes through ongoing charitable work. Flow-through trusts receive property that must be distributed to other qualified donees within specified timeframes.
Investment pooling trusts allow smaller restricted funds to benefit from professional management alongside larger holdings.
Exempt vs Non-Exempt Trusts: Core Differences
In Canadian tax law, the distinction between exempt and non-exempt trusts affects filing obligations and tax treatment. Exempt trusts avoid certain reporting requirements under the Income Tax Act, while non-exempt trusts face stricter compliance rules.
What Makes a Trust Exempt
A trust is exempt if it meets specific conditions in subsection 150(1.1) of the Income Tax Act. These exemptions allow certain trusts to avoid filing a T3 return and Schedule 15 under the enhanced trust reporting rules.
Trusts operated exclusively for charitable purposes typically qualify as exempt trusts. This includes registered charities that hold property in trust for their charitable activities.
The exemption recognizes that these trusts already face reporting requirements through their charitable registration. The ITA also exempts other specific trust types, such as mutual fund trusts, graduated rate estates, and qualified disability trusts.
Each category has distinct criteria for exempt status. Bill C-32 introduced new trust reporting rules for tax years ending on or after December 31, 2023.
These rules expanded filing requirements but maintained exemptions for trusts that pose lower risk for tax avoidance. The legislation aimed to increase transparency while not burdening low-risk trusts with unnecessary paperwork.
Criteria for Non-Exempt Trusts
Non-exempt trusts must file a T3 return and provide beneficial ownership information on Schedule 15. These trusts do not meet any of the exemption criteria listed in subsection 150(1.2) of the Income Tax Act.
The new trust reporting rules require non-exempt trusts to disclose all trustees, beneficiaries, settlors, and anyone with control over trustee decisions. This helps the Canada Revenue Agency identify potential tax avoidance structures.
Trusts must report even when they have no tax payable for the year. Most inter vivos trusts created during a settlor's lifetime are non-exempt.
Family trusts used for income splitting or estate planning usually require full reporting. The rules apply whether or not the trust generates income or distributes funds to beneficiaries.
Penalties apply for trusts that fail to file required returns. The CRA can assess penalties of $25 per day, up to a maximum of $2,500, for late filings.
Legal Implications for Charities
Charities that act as trustees face different compliance obligations depending on the trust structure. A registered charity operating its own charitable trust generally maintains exempt status because it already reports through its T3010 Charity Information Return.
Internal trusts held by registered charities are exempt from T3 filing requirements. On November 10, 2023, the Canada Revenue Agency clarified that registered charities are not required to file T3 returns for internal trusts. An internal trust is a donation held by a registered charity in the legal form of a trust.
This exemption applies to all internal trusts held by registered charities, regardless of whether they are characterized as express trusts or bare trusts. As long as the organization is a registered charity under the Income Tax Act, its internal trusts do not require separate T3 filings or Schedule 15 reporting.
However, if a charity serves as trustee for an external trust (a trust created independently by a donor or third party that does not qualify for exemption), it must file the required T3 return and Schedule 15 for that external trust.
Charities must also understand how exempt property rules apply. Trust property that generates income exempt from Canadian tax requires different treatment. This is important for charities receiving international donations or managing cross-border trusts.
The distinction affects estate planning strategies involving charitable giving. Donors who establish trusts to benefit charities need to structure them correctly to avoid unnecessary reporting burdens.
New Trust Reporting Requirements for Charities
Legislative changes introduced in December 2022 created new filing obligations for many trusts, including those held by charities. These rules require specific trusts to file T3 returns with detailed information about trustees and beneficiaries.
Registered charities receive certain exemptions. The Department of Finance enacted amendments through Bill C-32 that significantly changed trust reporting rules.
Recent Legislative Amendments
These changes apply to trusts with taxation years ending after December 30, 2023. The new rules require many trusts to file a T3 Trust Income Tax and Information Return within 90 days of year-end.
The amendments modified subsection 150(1.2) of the Income Tax Act. This section now lists specific trusts that qualify for exemptions from the reporting requirements.
The changes aimed to increase transparency and help the Canada Revenue Agency track beneficial ownership information. Bare trusts initially fell under these requirements but received relief in later guidance.
The August 2025 draft legislation provided additional clarifications for small family trusts and other arrangements.
Key Reporting Obligations
Trusts subject to the new rules must file the T3 Trust Income Tax and Information Return. This form requires detailed information about all trustees, beneficiaries, and settlors.
The trust must report each person's name, address, date of birth, and relationship to the trust. The filing deadline is 90 days after the trust's taxation year ends.
Trustees must maintain complete books and records to support the information provided. The CRA can impose significant penalties for non-compliance or late filing.
Internal trusts held by charities created uncertainty when the rules first appeared. These trusts are donations made to a registered charity in the legal form of a trust.
Universities, hospitals, and community foundations often hold many such arrangements, including endowment funds and donor-advised funds.
Exceptions for Registered Charities
Registered charities established as trusts do not need to file T3 returns under the new requirements. Paragraph 150(1.2)(d) of the Income Tax Act specifically exempts these entities.
Charities already file the T3010 Registered Charity Information Return, which contains detailed trust information. The Canada Revenue Agency clarified on November 10, 2023, that charities are not required to file T3 returns for internal trusts.
This guidance applies to all internal trusts held by registered charities, regardless of whether they are characterized as express trusts or bare trusts. The internal trust exemption for registered charities supersedes the general confusion surrounding bare trust reporting requirements.
This clarification maintained the CRA's longstanding administrative practice. The exemption prevents registered charities from filing separate returns for each donation received in trust form.
Trusts with total assets valued at $50,000 or less throughout the year also receive an exemption. Other exempt trusts include graduated rate estates, qualified disability trusts, and registered pension plans.
Client-specific trust accounts held by lawyers must still file, though general trust accounts do not.
Implications for Charity Governance and Operations
The trust structure a charity operates under affects how it manages resources and interacts with donors. Exempt trusts face fewer restrictions on asset accumulation.
Non-exempt trusts must actively deploy resources for charitable purposes. Registered charities must meet annual disbursement quota requirements regardless of trust type.
Disbursement Quota and Use of Assets
The Canada Revenue Agency requires most charities to spend at least 3.5% of the average value of their property not used in charitable activities. This rule applies to investment assets held by both exempt and non-exempt trusts.
Non-exempt trusts must use donated funds according to donor restrictions. When a donor specifies that money must support a specific purpose, the charity cannot redirect those funds to general operations.
The trust must track these restricted assets separately in its books and records. Exempt trusts have more flexibility in managing surplus funds.
If general donations exceed immediate program needs, the charity can invest the surplus without violating trust terms. This flexibility helps organizations build reserves for future activities or respond to unexpected opportunities.
Issuing Receipts and Donor Relations
Charities can issue official donation receipts for contributions to both exempt and non-exempt trusts. Donors must receive no direct benefit beyond the satisfaction of supporting charitable work.
All receipts must include the charity's registration number and meet Canada Revenue Agency format requirements. The donation receipt enables individual taxpayers to claim the charitable donation tax credit under Section 118.1 of the Income Tax Act. Corporate donors can claim a deduction under Section 110.1 of the Income Tax Act.
Restricted gifts create ongoing accountability to donors. When someone gives a large donation for a specific program, the charity must update them on how those funds were used.
The organization's books and records must clearly trace restricted funds from receipt through expenditure. Charities cannot treat restricted donations as gifts to qualified donees if they fail to honour donor intentions.
Redirecting funds violates both trust law and charity registration requirements. Serious breaches can lead to revocation of charitable status and loss of receipting privileges.
Tax Treatment and Compliance Issues
Canadian charities face different tax rules depending on whether they manage exempt or non-exempt trusts. The Income Tax Act sets out specific reporting requirements, disclosure obligations, and tax treatment based on trust classification.
Tax Exemption Status of Trusts
Internal trusts held by registered charities receive special treatment under the Income Tax Act. The CRA does not require charities to file a T3 Trust Income Tax and Information Return for these internal trusts.
These trusts form when a charity receives property as a gift with legally enforceable conditions and holds that property as trustee. External trusts operate under different rules.
A trust must file an annual T3 return if it has taxes payable for the year or distributes income or capital to beneficiaries. Inactive trusts with no tax payable generally avoid this filing requirement.
Registered charities must still complete their annual T3010 Registered Charity Information Return. This form requires details about all property the charity holds, including internal trusts.
The Canada Revenue Agency reviews these filings to ensure compliance with charitable status requirements.
GST/HST and Other Tax Considerations
Charities must follow Excise Tax Act rules for GST/HST alongside Income Tax Act provisions. Registered charities and non-profit organizations face different tax treatment for goods and services they provide.
The CRA guidelines specify how donations should be collected, managed, and reported. Charities need to maintain proper books and records for all financial activities.
This documentation supports their tax-exempt status and helps during CRA audits. Mismanagement of funds can lead to penalties or loss of charitable registration.
TIN and Beneficial Ownership Disclosure
The enhanced reporting rules under section 204.2 of the Income Tax Regulations require detailed disclosure for most trusts. These rules demand information such as names, addresses, dates of birth, jurisdiction of residence, and tax identification numbers (TIN) for settlors, trustees, and beneficiaries.
Internal trusts administered by charities are exempt from these enhanced disclosure requirements. This exemption saves charities from resource-intensive reporting and helps address privacy concerns.
False statements or omissions on T3 returns result in significant penalties. Charities must use current forms and provide accurate information to stay compliant with the Canada Revenue Agency.
Legal Structures Underpinning Charitable Trusts
Charitable trusts in Canada operate under different legal frameworks than corporate structures. While most charities incorporate as not-for-profit corporations, trusts are still used for specific charitable purposes and endowment management.
Trusts vs Not-for-Profit Corporations
A charitable trust differs from a not-for-profit corporation in its legal nature and structure. A trust exists when a donor transfers property to trustees to hold for specific charitable purposes.
The trust document or deed sets out these purposes and management rules. Trustees have a fiduciary duty to manage the trust property according to these terms.
A not-for-profit corporation is a separate legal entity created through incorporation. Organizations can incorporate federally under the Canada Not-for-profit Corporations Act or under provincial legislation.
Corporations have directors, members, and formal governance structures set out in articles of incorporation and bylaws.
The key differences include:
Legal personality: Corporations are separate legal entities; trusts are not.
Governance: Corporations have directors and members; trusts have trustees.
Liability protection: Corporations provide limited liability; trustees may face personal liability.
Flexibility: Corporations can more easily amend purposes and structure; trust terms are often harder to change.
Formality: Corporations require incorporation documents and ongoing filings; trusts operate under trust deeds.
Most modern charities choose incorporation for limited liability protection and operational flexibility. Trusts are useful for holding endowments or when donors want to place specific restrictions on charitable property.
Trusts and Provincial Legislation
Provincial trust legislation governs how charitable trusts operate and how courts can modify them. Each province has trustee acts that set out trustees' powers and duties.
Some provinces have specific charitable trust legislation addressing particular issues. The cy-près doctrine allows courts to modify trust purposes when the original purposes become impossible or impractical to fulfil.
Provincial legislation and common law guide how courts apply this doctrine. Courts can redirect charitable property to similar purposes while respecting donor intent as closely as possible.
Provincial legislation also governs:
- Trustee investment powers and standards of care
- Rules for trustee compensation
- Requirements for trust accounting and reporting
- Powers to deviate from trust terms in certain circumstances
Trustees must understand both provincial trust law and federal tax law requirements. The Charities Accounting Act in some provinces provides additional oversight for certain charitable trusts.
Unincorporated Associations and Their Roles
An unincorporated association is a group of people working together for a common purpose without formal incorporation. These associations lack separate legal personality, and members may face personal liability for the association's obligations.
Unincorporated associations can operate as charities if they meet Canada Revenue Agency requirements. Most choose to incorporate to gain limited liability protection and clearer legal status.
Some small community groups or religious congregations remain unincorporated due to their informal nature or size. These associations face practical challenges:
- Difficulty entering contracts in the organization's name
- Problems holding property or opening bank accounts
- Potential personal liability for members
- Limited ability to sue or be sued as an entity
The Canada Not-for-profit Corporations Act made federal incorporation more accessible. Provincial incorporation options also exist for organizations operating mainly within one province.
Conclusion
Canadian charities benefit from clear exemptions for internal trusts under the enhanced trust reporting rules. On November 10, 2023, the Canada Revenue Agency confirmed that registered charities are not required to file T3 returns for internal trusts.
This exemption applies to all donations held by registered charities in the legal form of a trust, including endowment funds, restricted gifts, and donor-advised funds. As long as an organization maintains its status as a registered charity under the Income Tax Act, its internal trusts are exempt from both T3 filing and Schedule 15 beneficial ownership reporting.
Organizations should understand the distinction between internal trusts (which are exempt) and external trusts for which the charity may serve as trustee (which may require filing). For external trusts that do not qualify for exemption, charities must determine their filing obligations and gather the required information about trustees, settlors, and beneficiaries.
The CRA has indicated it will waive penalties for the initial implementation years for many trusts unless there is evidence of gross negligence. However, charities should still maintain accurate records and understand their obligations to avoid future compliance issues.
B&H Charity Accounting Firm helps Canadian charities navigate trust reporting requirements and stay compliant with CRA regulations. Organizations can call (289) 301-8883, visit charityaccountingfirm.ca, or schedule a FREE consultation to discuss their specific trust reporting needs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Canadian charities face specific tax treatment and trust reporting rules. The Canada Revenue Agency sets standards for charitable status, trust classifications, and filing obligations.
Are Canadian charities tax-exempt?
Canadian charities are tax-exempt when they maintain registered status with the Canada Revenue Agency. They do not pay income tax on their charitable activities.
Registered charities must follow specific rules to keep their tax-exempt status. They need to file annual T3010 information returns and operate exclusively for charitable purposes.
A charity can lose its tax-exempt status if it fails to meet compliance requirements. The CRA may revoke registration if a charity lends its registration number to another organization or does not account for donations properly.
What is a non-exempt charitable trust?
A non-exempt charitable trust is a trust that does not qualify for any of the specific exemptions under the Income Tax Act. These trusts must file T3 returns and include Schedule 15 with beneficial ownership information.
Non-exempt trusts face enhanced reporting requirements for taxation years ending on or after December 31, 2023. They must report detailed information about all trustees, settlors, beneficiaries, and controlling persons.
The classification depends on whether the trust meets certain conditions set by the CRA. Trusts that exceed the $50,000 threshold or do not qualify for other exemptions fall into the non-exempt category.
What is an exempt trust for a Canadian charity?
An exempt trust for a Canadian charity is one that meets specific exemption criteria under the Income Tax Act. These trusts may not need to file T3 returns or provide beneficial ownership information in some cases.
Listed trusts are one type of exempt trust that only file T3 returns in specific situations. They are not required to include Schedule 15 when they do file.
The CRA clarified on November 10, 2023, that charities are not required to file T3 information returns for internal trusts. Internal trusts are donations held by registered charities in the legal form of trusts.
Why does exempt vs non-exempt status matter for a Canadian charity?
The distinction affects filing obligations and administrative burden for charities. Non-exempt trusts require more detailed reporting and compliance work.
Charities are responsible for all tax receipts issued under their name and registration number. They must account for corresponding donations on their annual information return.
Misclassification can lead to penalties or missed filing deadlines. The enhanced reporting rules help the CRA verify that trusts and their related parties have met their tax obligations.
What are the reporting requirements for exempt and non-exempt trusts associated with Canadian charities?
Non-exempt trusts must file annual T3 returns with Schedule 15 for taxation years ending on or after December 31, 2023. Schedule 15 requires detailed information about all reportable entities connected to the trust.
Exempt trusts have reduced filing requirements. Listed trusts only file T3 returns in specific situations and do not need to include Schedule 15.
Internal charitable trusts do not need to file T3 returns based on CRA guidance from November 2023. This exemption applies to all internal trusts held by registered charities, whether they are characterized as express trusts or bare trusts. The exemption prevents charities from filing separate returns for each donation received in trust form.
For registered charities, the internal trust exemption supersedes the general complexity surrounding bare trust reporting requirements that affected other taxpayers during the 2023 and 2024 taxation years.
Are there any specific provincial regulations in Canada that impact exempt or non-exempt trusts for charities?
Provincial regulations for charities exist. However, the Income Tax Act is federal legislation.
The CRA administers trust reporting rules for the federal government and most provinces. Charities must comply with both federal and provincial requirements where applicable.
Provincial charity legislation may add governance and reporting obligations. The trust reporting requirements under the Income Tax Act apply across Canada.
The $50,000 threshold and exemption criteria use Canadian dollar values for foreign currency calculations.
Legal Sources & References
Follow Us
